Since 2008 · Next open Train the Trainer workshops: 18–21 Nov, Mumbai · 9–12 Dec, Bengaluru · 8 open batches in 2027, Mumbai & Bengaluru
AssessAll & assessments

The Effort Recession: Why India's Extra Mile Is Shrinking

Ask any team lead in Bengaluru, Gurugram or Pune whether their people work hard, and you will hear the same answer: of course they do . Late calls with US clients. Weekend deployments. WhatsApp messages at 10:40 pm that get a reply by 10:42.

In brief

Indians log the most unpaid hours in the world, yet 63% of firms see extra effort falling. Why hours can be demanded, but effort can only be given.

Key takeaways

  • The fall was reported to be steepest in IT, professional services, and construction, infrastructure and real estate.
  • The fix sits with managers: making extra effort visible and recognised, protecting time for it, ending "always-on" as the default, and leading a workforce in which Gen Z's share has doubled from 13% to 26% since 2023.

Last updated · Bodhih Insights team · reviewed by Siddharthan VGJ, Founder

The Effort Recession: Why India's Extra Mile Is Shrinking

Now ask a different question: when did someone on your team last fix a problem nobody asked them to fix?

That one takes longer to answer.

Two pieces of research from 2026 put numbers on this gap, and side by side they make a strange picture. According to ADP's People at Work 2026 study, India has the highest share of workers in the world doing 16 or more unpaid hours a week. And according to Great Place To Work India, 63% of Indian organisations have seen employees' willingness to go beyond their job description fall year on year. GPTW calls it an "effort recession".

So Indian employees are working more unpaid hours than anyone, and giving less extra effort than before. Both are true at once. Understanding why is one of the most useful things a leader can learn this year.

01

What Is an "Effort Recession"?

Discretionary effort is the effort an employee chooses to give beyond what their role strictly requires. It is the analyst who spots a pattern in the data that nobody asked about. The support agent who follows up the next day to make sure the fix worked. The engineer who documents the workaround so the next person does not lose a day. The senior who stops to help a new joiner.

None of this appears in a KRA. All of it shows up in results: quality, customer loyalty, innovation and how fast teams learn.

An effort recession is a broad, sustained fall in that voluntary effort across many organisations at once. It is not people refusing to do their jobs. It is people doing their jobs, and stopping there.

What the 2026 research says Finding
Indian organisations reporting a year-on-year fall in discretionary effort (GPTW India) 63%
Fall in discretionary effort since 2023 (GPTW India) About 4%
Willing to give extra effort where caring, inspiring leadership is strongly felt (GPTW India) 90%
Willing to give extra effort in the bottom-quartile companies (GPTW India) 75%
Indian workers doing 16+ unpaid hours a week (ADP) 24% (global: 12%)
Indian workers doing 6–15 unpaid hours a week (ADP) 40%
Indian employees engaged at work, 2025 (Gallup) 23%
Gen Z share of India's workforce, 2023 → 2026 (GPTW India) 13% → 26%

A word on the numbers. GPTW's figures come from its own certification surveys of companies that chose to take part, which tend to be better-run workplaces than average. ADP's figures are self-reported by workers. Some details above come from press coverage of the reports rather than the full reports. Read them as strong signals, not exact measurements. But if the effort recession shows up even among companies applying to be called great workplaces, it is unlikely to be milder elsewhere.

02

The Paradox: Record Unpaid Hours, Falling Extra Effort

At first glance, the two findings contradict each other. If people are giving away 16 hours a week, how can they be giving less extra effort?

The answer is that hours and effort are not the same thing, and in many Indian workplaces they have been confused for years.

Look at what most of those unpaid hours actually are:

Unpaid hours (often expected) Discretionary effort (always chosen)
Joining the 9 pm call because the client is in New York Suggesting a way to make the 9 pm call unnecessary
Replying to messages on Sunday Fixing the process that keeps creating Sunday messages
Staying late because the manager is still online Staying late because you care how the launch goes
Clearing the backlog Spotting why the backlog keeps building
Being visible Being useful

The left-hand column can be required, monitored and extracted. The right-hand column cannot. It only exists when people have the energy, the trust and the reason to give it.

The new insight: an organisation can fill every evening with work and still be running low on effort. Unpaid hours are often the cost of a low-effort system, not proof of a high-effort culture. The meetings that could have been emails, the rework, the late approvals: someone pays for them in hours, and the hours leave less room for the extra mile.

ADP's own observation supports this: in its data, more unpaid hours did not mean more output, but did mean more stress and more people thinking about leaving.

03

Why Extra Effort Disappears When You Demand It

Researchers who study what they call organisational citizenship behaviour (the formal name for discretionary effort) have found something counter-intuitive that explains a lot of the effort recession.

"Job creep": when the extra mile becomes the required mile

Management researchers Linn Van Dyne and Jennifer Ellis described a process they called job creep. Extra effort that people once gave voluntarily slowly becomes expected. The weekend check-in that started as a favour becomes a norm. The helpful senior who reviewed everyone's slides becomes the person who must review them. Once that happens, the effort is no longer discretionary. It is unpaid work, and people quietly start to resent it.

"Citizenship fatigue": pressured goodwill burns out

In a 2015 study in the Journal of Applied Psychology, Mark Bolino, Hsin-Hua Hsiung, Jaron Harvey and Jeffery LePine identified citizenship fatigue: feeling worn out, tired or on edge because of going above and beyond. They found it was more likely when people felt pressure to do extra, had low support from the organisation and had weaker relationships with their teammates. And crucially, citizenship fatigue was followed by less extra effort later.

Put the two ideas together and the effort recession starts to make sense:

  1. People go the extra mile.
  2. The organisation starts to expect it (job creep).
  3. The expectation, plus long hours and thin support, wears people out (citizenship fatigue).
  4. People pull back to protect themselves.
  5. Leaders see falling commitment and push harder, which repeats the cycle.

This is why "we need more ownership" town halls rarely work. Asking for discretionary effort, or making it a target, is one of the surest ways to reduce it.

04

Why Better Perks Didn't Fix It

GPTW's analysis makes an important point: the effort recession is not simply because workplaces got worse. Many companies have improved benefits, policies and employee experience since 2023. That has not turned into more commitment.

The reason is that perks and effort work on different levels. A good health plan, a better canteen or a new hybrid policy makes a job more acceptable. It answers the question "should I stay?". Discretionary effort answers a different question: "do I care enough to do more than I have to?". That answer comes mainly from daily experience with a manager and a team.

GPTW's data points the same way: caring and inspiring leadership is among the strongest predictors of extra effort. Gallup's long-running research finds that managers account for most of the variation in team engagement. The extra mile is not bought through HR policy. It is earned, or lost, in one-on-ones, team meetings and everyday decisions about who gets credit.

05

Four Forces Behind India's Effort Recession

1. The visibility problem

When recognition, progress or meaning at work cannot be seen, discretionary effort tends to fall. In large, matrixed and hybrid organisations, a lot of extra effort happens out of sight: the bug fixed quietly, the client saved by a well-timed call. If nobody notices, people learn that the extra mile is invisible, and stop walking it.

2. A workforce that has changed faster than its managers

Gen Z's share of India's workforce has doubled from 13% to 26% since 2023, according to GPTW. Reporting on the same research says nearly 58% of CHROs are managing AI transformation and generational change at the same time, and 1 in 2 CHROs admit they do not clearly understand what motivates younger employees. Many younger professionals are not less willing to work hard. They are less willing to give effort that is unseen, unexplained or taken for granted. Leadership habits built for "do it because I said so" do not draw out their best work.

3. AI uncertainty

AI is changing roles across Indian IT, services and operations, and the same GPTW research reported that 1 in 4 CHROs expect AI-driven workforce cuts. When people are unsure whether their role will exist next year, extra effort feels like a bad investment. Why build deep expertise in a process that might be automated? GPTW itself warns that AI can create new tensions at work. India also leads ADP's list for daily AI use (41% of workers), so the uncertainty is not abstract; people are living with it every day.

4. Burnout at the edges

GPTW reported that 13% of employees are in a high-burnout category. Add record unpaid hours, and a large share of the workforce simply has no spare energy left to give. You cannot draw on goodwill that has already been spent.

06

The Manager's Playbook for Ending the Effort Recession

The good news in the GPTW data is the gap between 90% and 75%. Leadership behaviour moves discretionary effort, and leadership behaviour can be learned. Here is where to start.

01

Separate effort from hours, and say so out loud

Stop praising late-night replies and weekend availability. Praise the improvement, the idea, the help given to a colleague. What managers recognise is what teams repeat. If "always online" is what gets noticed, that is what you will get, and the real extra mile will keep shrinking.

02

Find and remove the work that eats the evenings

Before asking for more effort, take away wasted effort: unnecessary status meetings, slow approvals, duplicate reports, rework caused by unclear briefs. Every hour returned to people is an hour that can go towards discretionary work. Mastering time management and effective delegation help managers and teams protect focus time.

03

Make extra effort visible, specific and fair

Recognition does not need to be expensive. It needs to be specific ("the way you handled the escalation saved the account") and fair (not always the same three people). Regular one-on-one meetings and good giving and receiving feedback skills are where most of this happens.

04

Stop job creep before it starts

When someone goes above and beyond, thank them, and then ask whether they want it to become part of their role. If it should, make it official: adjust their goals, workload or title. If not, do not quietly assume it will continue. This single habit protects your most generous people from becoming your most exhausted ones.

5. Lead with care, not only with targets

GPTW's strongest predictor of extra effort is caring and inspiring leadership. In practice, that means knowing your people, explaining the why behind decisions and connecting daily work to a purpose people can believe in. Empathetic leadership training, leading with trust and psychological safety training build these behaviours in practical, measurable ways.

6. Learn what motivates a younger workforce

Gen Z employees often want clear reasons, regular feedback, visible growth and a sense that their contribution counts. Managing Gen Z employees and leading multigenerational teams help managers adapt without lowering standards. Career conversations training helps managers show people where their effort can take them.

7. Be honest about AI

Uncertainty kills extra effort faster than bad news. Tell people what you know and what you do not know about how AI will change their roles, and show them how to build skills that stay valuable. AI for leaders, leading human-AI teams and the human skills for the AI era programme give managers and teams a practical path through the change.

8. Watch for burnout and act early

Managers are often the first to see the warning signs: shorter replies, missed details, withdrawal from team activities. Manager mental health training and employee wellbeing programmes help leaders notice and respond before good people burn out.

07

Why This Matters for India

India's competitive story with global clients has long rested on something beyond cost: the willingness of people to solve problems, anticipate needs and go further than the contract says. That is discretionary effort, and it is exactly what the effort recession erodes.

The sectors where GPTW saw the steepest fall (IT, professional services, and construction and infrastructure) are some of the country's largest employers and most important to its growth. As AI takes over more routine tasks, the work that remains will rely even more on the human qualities that come from discretionary effort: judgement, initiative and care for the outcome. An organisation that wins back its people's extra mile will have an advantage that is very hard to copy.

If you want a quick view of where your managers stand, our free first-time manager readiness check is a good starting point, and employee engagement training covers the programmes that help most.

08

A Six-Question Check for Your Organisation

  1. Do we recognise results and ideas, or mainly availability and hours?
  2. Which recurring meetings, approvals or reports could we remove to give people time back?
  3. Who are our most generous colleagues, and has their extra effort quietly become part of their unpaid job?
  4. Would our employees say their manager cares about them as a person?
  5. Do our managers understand what motivates the Gen Z members of their teams?
  6. Have we told our people honestly how AI will affect their roles, and how we will help them grow?
09

The Bigger Story: The Extra Mile Is a Gift

The effort recession is not a story about lazy employees. The ADP data shows Indian professionals are giving more of their time than almost anyone in the world. It is a story about what happens when goodwill is treated as a resource to be extracted instead of a gift to be earned.

The answer is not to ask for more. It is to ask for less waste, notice more of what people already give and lead in a way that makes people want to go further. The companies that understand this will not need a town hall about ownership. Their people will simply show it.

Bodhih helps organisations across India build the leadership behaviours that bring discretionary effort back, from first-time manager training to empathetic leadership, trust and engagement programmes, delivered in person and virtually. Talk to us about your managers and teams.

10

Frequently asked questions

What is the "effort recession"?

The "effort recession" is a term used by Great Place To Work India in its 2026 research to describe a broad fall in employees' discretionary effort, meaning their willingness to go beyond their formal job description. GPTW found discretionary effort had fallen about 4% since 2023, with 63% of Indian organisations reporting a year-on-year decline.

What is discretionary effort at work?

Discretionary effort is the extra effort an employee chooses to give beyond what their role strictly requires, such as helping colleagues, suggesting improvements, fixing problems no one assigned or following up with a customer. It cannot be demanded or fully measured, but it strongly affects quality, innovation and customer loyalty.

Why is discretionary effort declining in India?

Research points to several causes: extra effort that goes unrecognised, long working hours and burnout, uncertainty about how AI will change jobs, and leadership styles that have not adapted to a younger workforce. GPTW found that improved benefits have not increased commitment, and that caring and inspiring leadership is one of the strongest predictors of extra effort.

How many unpaid hours do Indian employees work?

According to ADP's People at Work 2026 study of more than 39,000 workers in 36 markets, 24% of Indian workers do 16 or more unpaid hours a week, the highest share of any market and about double the global figure of 12%. A further 40% do 6 to 15 unpaid hours a week. ADP found that longer unpaid hours did not lead to higher output.

If Indians work so many unpaid hours, how can effort be falling?

Hours and discretionary effort are different. Many unpaid hours are expected, such as late client calls or after-hours messages. Discretionary effort is voluntary, such as improving a process or helping a colleague. Long, expected hours can actually reduce discretionary effort by using up the energy and goodwill people need to go the extra mile.

What is citizenship fatigue?

Citizenship fatigue is a term from a 2015 study in the Journal of Applied Psychology by Bolino, Hsiung, Harvey and LePine. It describes feeling worn out or on edge because of going above and beyond at work. It is more likely when people feel pressured to do extra and have little support, and it leads to less extra effort later.

How can managers increase discretionary effort?

Managers can recognise ideas and results rather than hours, remove wasted work, make extra effort visible and fair, stop voluntary effort quietly becoming an unpaid duty, show genuine care for team members, adapt to what motivates younger employees and communicate honestly about AI. GPTW found 90% of employees are willing to give extra effort where caring, inspiring leadership is strongly felt.

What training helps reverse an effort recession?

Useful programmes include first-time manager training, empathetic leadership, leading with trust, psychological safety, one-on-one meetings and feedback skills, managing Gen Z and multigenerational teams, career conversations, manager mental health and AI-era leadership. Bodhih offers these as practical programmes for organisations across India.

Where do these facts come from?

Great Place To Work India, Companies To Work For 2026 and India's Great Mid-size Workplaces 2026 (more than 5.7 million employees, 20+ industries), as reported by GPTW India, CXOToday, Outlook Money, Free Press Journal, People Matters and other Indian media; ADP Research, People at Work 2026 (39,000+ workers, 36 markets), as reported by Business Standard and The People's Board; Gallup, State of the Global Workplace 2026; Bolino, Hsiung, Harvey and LePine, Journal of Applied Psychology (2015); Van Dyne and Ellis on job creep (2004). Some figures come from press summaries of the original research and should be read as indicative.

Keep reading

More on AssessAll & assessments

All articles
Leadership
The Layoff Shadow: Damage Starts Before the Cuts
Leadership · 18 Nov 2026

The Layoff Shadow: Damage Starts Before the Cuts

56% of firms expect layoffs in early 2027. Research shows fearing job loss can hurt as much as the loss itself. How managers can lead through the

Read article →
Leadership
The AI Trust Penalty: Use AI, Lose Your Boss's Trust
Leadership · 15 Nov 2026

The AI Trust Penalty: Use AI, Lose Your Boss's Trust

New 2026 research: managers trust employees who use AI less, even when they asked for it. Why it happens, and how leaders and L&D can fix it.

Read article →
Leadership
The Escalation Reflex: Why Managers Pass Conflict Up
Leadership · 14 Nov 2026

The Escalation Reflex: Why Managers Pass Conflict Up

2026 research shows managers escalate conflict instead of resolving it. What the escalation reflex costs Indian teams, and how to train it out.

Read article →
AssessAll & assessments
DISC and Harrison Assessments in India: How Behavioral Data Transforms Hiring and Leadership
AssessAll & assessments · 15 Oct 2026

DISC and Harrison Assessments in India: How Behavioral Data Transforms Hiring and Leadership

DISC vs Harrison assessments: how four DISC styles differ from Harrison trait and paradox data, and how Indian firms use each for hiring and

Read article →
AssessAll & assessments
Training – A Discredited Affair
AssessAll & assessments · 15 Oct 2026

Training – A Discredited Affair

Why corporate training is discredited: business heads treat it as a favour to HR, two-day workshops get cut to one, and the results suffer as a

Read article →
Leadership
Labour Codes at One: The Gap Is Now on the Shop Floor
Leadership · 13 Nov 2026

Labour Codes at One: The Gap Is Now on the Shop Floor

India's Labour Codes turn one on 21 Nov 2026. Payroll has adapted; the bigger risk now sits in daily decisions by supervisors and line managers.

Read article →
Let’s talk

Ready to grow your people? Let’s design it together.

Since 2008, Bodhih has designed learning for 2,000+ organisations across 7 regions. Tell us what you need.

Get a tailored proposal Book a meeting with a consultantFree 30-min video call at a time you pick · +91 99000 11601 · solutions@bodhih.com