New 2026 data: 87% of employees know what good work looks like, but only 50% see poor performance addressed. Your best people pay the price.
Key takeaways
- That 50% has barely moved since 2021, when it was 49%. Five years of performance-management redesigns, new HR tech and new rating scales have not changed it.
- A separate October 2026 survey of 1,000 US workers by MyPerfectResume found 78% have deliberately done only the minimum required to keep their job, and 69% limited their effort because pay did not match what was expected of them.
- Research on team behaviour shows the cost spreads. In Will Felps' widely cited experiments, a single planted "bad apple" was enough to drag group performance down sharply, and the rest of the team often started to copy the behaviour.
- Leadership IQ found that only 17% of middle managers feel comfortable improving or removing low performers.
- The problem is rarely a lack of policy. It is a skills gap in managers: the ability to name a performance problem early, hold a clear conversation, and follow through. That can be taught.
Last updated · Bodhih Insights team · reviewed by Siddharthan VGJ, Founder

Priya closes her tickets on time, double-checks the client numbers, and stays late when a release slips. Arjun misses deadlines, sends half-finished work, and is "on leave" every time a crunch arrives. Everyone on the team knows this. Their manager knows it too.
At appraisal time, both get a "meets expectations". Both get the same increment. And Priya, without telling anyone, makes a quiet decision: from now on, I'll do exactly what I'm paid for. Nothing more.
Nobody resigned. Nobody complained. But the team just lost its best performer, and it will not show up in any report for months.
This is the fairness tax: the hidden cost an organisation pays when underperformance is visible to everyone but addressed by no one. New data released in November 2026 suggests most organisations are paying it.
The Number That Has Not Moved in Five Years
Most performance data gets worse or better over time. This one stays flat.
Culture Amp's benchmarks show that employees are not confused about expectations. Nearly nine in ten say they know what good work looks like. The gap is in what happens next. Only half believe anything happens when someone falls short.
Culture Amp's 2027 predictions, published on 10 November 2026, point out that this figure has moved just one point since 2021. In the same period, organisations have rolled out OKRs, continuous feedback tools, new rating scales and, now, AI-assisted reviews. The tools changed. The follow-through did not.
The benchmarks also flag related gaps: goals that are set but never revisited, decision rights that are never clarified, and AI strategies that change without being explained. The common thread is simple. Organisations are good at setting expectations and poor at acting on them.
Why This Is a High-Performer Problem, Not a Low-Performer Problem
When leaders hear "underperformance", they picture the struggling employee. But the person most affected is usually the one sitting next to them.
High performers notice everything. They see who is carrying the load, who misses deadlines without consequence, and who gets the same rating anyway. When they conclude that effort and outcomes are not linked, they adjust, and the adjustment is almost always downwards.
Psychologists have a name for the logic underneath this. Equity theory, first set out by J. Stacy Adams in the 1960s, says people constantly compare what they put in and what they get out with what others put in and get out. When the comparison feels unfair, people restore balance. They rarely do it by asking for more. They do it by giving less.
That is exactly what the MyPerfectResume data shows:
| What workers reported (MyPerfectResume, Oct 2026) | Share |
|---|---|
| Have intentionally done only the minimum required to keep their job | 78% |
| Do this frequently or occasionally | 49% |
| Limited effort because pay did not match expectations | 69% |
| Asked to take on work outside their job description without extra pay | 86% |
Read the last line next to the Culture Amp finding. When underperformance goes unaddressed, the missing work does not disappear. It gets quietly reassigned to whoever is reliable. The reward for being good at your job becomes more of someone else's job.
How One Person Changes a Whole Team
Will Felps, then at the University of Washington, ran a now-famous set of experiments with Terence Mitchell and Eliza Byington. Small teams worked on a problem-solving task. In some teams, an actor was planted to behave badly: as a "slacker" who did not contribute, a "jerk" who attacked others, or a "depressive pessimist".
The results, published as How, when, and why bad apples spoil the barrel (Research in Organizational Behavior, 2006), were striking:
- Teams with a single bad apple performed noticeably worse than teams without one, even when the other members were talented.
- Other members started to mirror the behaviour. When the slacker stopped trying, others eased off too.
- The few teams that held up usually had one person who actively managed the situation: drawing people in, asking questions, keeping the group focused.
That last point is the lesson for managers. The difference between a team that absorbs a weak performer and a team that is dragged down by one is usually someone who steps in. In most organisations, that someone is supposed to be the manager.
Why Managers Avoid It, Especially in India
If addressing underperformance is so important, why do half of organisations not do it? Leadership IQ's research gives one blunt answer: only 14% of senior executives say their company manages low performers well, and only 17% of middle managers feel comfortable improving or removing them.
In Indian workplaces, several familiar patterns make avoidance even easier.
- 1. "Adjust karo" culture. Teams are expected to absorb problems and maintain harmony. Raising a colleague's performance can feel like breaking the group, so managers redistribute the work instead.
- 2. Appraisal-season compression. Many Indian organisations still run a single annual cycle, often in March or April. Problems noticed in July are saved for "the review", by which time they are eight months old, the evidence is vague, and the conversation feels like an ambush.
- 3. The relationship trap. Many first-line managers were promoted from within and now manage former peers or friends. Having a hard conversation with someone you had lunch with last year is genuinely difficult, and most new managers receive no training for it. We explored this in The Accidental Manager.
- 4. Fear of attrition. In tight talent markets, managers worry that a firm conversation will cause the person to leave, and that replacing them will take months. So they tolerate it. The irony is that the person most likely to leave is the high performer watching it happen.
- 5. Escalation instead of conversation. Instead of addressing the issue directly, managers pass it to HR or to their own boss. We wrote about this pattern in The Escalation Reflex.
- 6. The rating-scale escape. Forced distributions and bell curves let managers hide behind the system: "I had to give someone a 2." The employee hears the rating but never hears what to change.
What Good Follow-Through Looks Like
Organisations that close the gap do not usually have tougher policies. They have managers who do a few small things consistently.
Name it early, and name it specifically
The best time to address a performance issue is the first or second time you notice it, not at the annual review. Use specific, observable facts: "The last three client reports went out after the deadline, and two had errors in the totals." Not: "Your attitude needs to improve."
Separate the "can't" from the "won't"
Underperformance has different causes: unclear expectations, missing skills, personal circumstances, poor fit, or low motivation. Each needs a different response. A short diagnostic conversation ("What's getting in the way?") prevents managers from treating a skills gap as an attitude problem, or the other way round.
Agree a clear, short plan
Write down what needs to change, by when, what support will be provided, and when you will check in. Two to six weeks is usually enough to see whether things are moving.
Follow up, visibly
The Culture Amp data shows that the gap is follow-through. A conversation without a check-in teaches everyone that conversations do not matter. Put the follow-up in the calendar on the same day as the first conversation.
Protect your reliable people
Stop routing extra work to the same dependable people by default. When you redistribute work, say so openly, explain why, and make it temporary. Recognise publicly the people who are carrying more.
Calibrate across managers
If one manager addresses issues and another never does, employees will notice the unfairness across teams too. Regular calibration conversations help managers apply the same standard.
Old Habits vs Better Habits
| What many managers do today | What closes the fairness gap |
|---|---|
| Save problems for the annual appraisal | Address issues within days, in a short private conversation |
| Talk about attitude and effort in general terms | Describe specific, observable work and its impact |
| Quietly move work to reliable people | Redistribute openly, temporarily, and with recognition |
| Escalate to HR at the first difficulty | Hold the first two conversations themselves, with HR as backup |
| Use the rating scale to deliver the message | Use the rating to record a message already delivered |
| Assume the person knows they are underperforming | Check understanding and agree what "good" looks like |
What This Means for HR and L&D Leaders
Most organisations do not need a new performance policy. They need managers who can use the one they already have. Here is a practical sequence.
- Measure the gap in your own organisation. Add one question to your next pulse survey: "When someone in my team underperforms, it is addressed." Compare the result by team. The spread between managers is usually more revealing than the average.
- Train managers in the conversation itself. Knowing the process is not enough. Managers need practice holding a clear, respectful performance conversation, with role-plays on the situations they actually face. Our performance management training and high-stakes conversations training are built around exactly this.
- Build the feedback habit before the crisis. Teams where feedback flows weekly find performance conversations far less dramatic. Giving and receiving feedback and coaching for managers build this muscle.
- Make accountability a team norm, not just a manager's job. Accountability at work training helps teams agree what "owning it" looks like, so peers can raise issues with each other before they escalate.
- Fix the appraisal moment. If your annual review is where problems are first raised, the review is too late. Delivering effective performance appraisals helps managers turn reviews into a summary of conversations already held.
- Start with new managers. New managers form their habits in the first year. First-time manager training is the right place to teach that addressing underperformance is part of the job, not a failure of the relationship.
- Keep it safe. Firm conversations work best in teams where people trust that feedback is meant to help. Psychological safety training and leading with trust make directness feel fair rather than threatening.
- Connect it to culture. If you want a team where good work is noticed and poor work is addressed, start with developing a high-performance culture.
Not sure whether your newest managers are ready for these conversations? Try our free first-time manager readiness check. It takes a few minutes and needs no sign-up.
A Five-Question Check for Your Next Leadership Meeting
- If a high performer in our organisation watched a colleague underperform for six months, would they see any consequence?
- How long, on average, does it take between a manager noticing a performance issue and raising it?
- Do our managers know how to hold a performance conversation, or have they only been told the process?
- Who is quietly absorbing the extra work in our teams, and do we recognise them for it?
- Would our employees agree with the statement "Underperformance is addressed here"? Have we asked?
The Bigger Story: Fairness Is a Performance Strategy
For years, organisations have tried to lift performance by adding things: new goals, new tools, new incentives. The Culture Amp data suggests a simpler place to start. People already know what good looks like. What they need to see is that it matters.
When underperformance is addressed calmly, early and consistently, three things happen. The struggling employee gets a real chance to improve. The team stops copying the lowest standard. And the high performers, the Priyas of your organisation, see that their effort is noticed.
That is not about being tough. It is about being fair. And fairness, it turns out, is one of the most underrated performance strategies an organisation has.
Bodhih designs practical performance management, feedback and leadership programmes for organisations across India, in person and virtually. Talk to us about building managers who follow through.
Frequently asked questions
What is the fairness tax at work?
The fairness tax is the hidden cost an organisation pays when underperformance is visible to colleagues but not addressed by managers. High performers notice that effort and outcomes are not linked, take on extra work, and often respond by reducing their own discretionary effort or leaving. The cost rarely shows in reports until it becomes attrition.
How many employees say underperformance is addressed at their organisation?
According to Culture Amp's Performance Culture benchmarks, released in November 2026 and based on employee survey data collected between July 2025 and July 2026, only 50% of employees say their organisation takes action when someone underperforms, even though 87% say they know what high performance looks like. Culture Amp reports the figure was 49% in 2021.
Why do managers avoid addressing poor performance?
Common reasons include discomfort with difficult conversations, fear that the employee will leave, close personal relationships with former peers, waiting for the annual appraisal, and lack of training. Leadership IQ research found only 17% of middle managers feel comfortable improving or removing low performers. In India, a strong preference for team harmony can add to this avoidance.
How does tolerating low performers affect high performers?
High performers often absorb the extra work and see that poor performance carries no consequence. Equity theory suggests they restore a sense of fairness by reducing their own effort. Research by Felps, Mitchell and Byington found that a single poorly performing team member can lower the performance of a whole group, as others begin to copy the behaviour.
What is the right way to address underperformance?
Raise it early and privately, describe specific and observable work rather than attitude, find out whether the cause is unclear expectations, missing skills, personal circumstances or motivation, agree a short written plan with support, and follow up on a fixed date. The follow-up is the step most organisations miss.
Is "quiet quitting" linked to unaddressed underperformance?
They are closely related. A 2026 MyPerfectResume survey of 1,000 US workers found 78% had intentionally done only the minimum required, and 86% had been given work outside their job description without extra pay. When managers move work from underperformers to reliable employees, those reliable employees are the most likely to cut back.
What training helps managers address underperformance?
The most useful programmes combine performance management basics with plenty of practice: holding a performance conversation, giving specific feedback, coaching for improvement, setting clear goals and following up. Bodhih's performance management, high-stakes conversations, feedback, coaching for managers and first-time manager programmes are designed around these skills.
Where do these facts come from?
Culture Amp, Performance Culture benchmarks (press release, November 2026) and 2027 predictions (10 November 2026); MyPerfectResume, Act Your Wage survey of 1,000 US workers (October 2026); Felps, Mitchell and Byington, How, when, and why bad apples spoil the barrel: Negative group members and dysfunctional groups, Research in Organizational Behavior (2006); Leadership IQ research on managing low performers; and J. Stacy Adams' equity theory (1963, 1965). Some figures come from press summaries of the research and should be read as indicative.






